A violent uprising in New York City sparked by Civil War military conscription that resulted in over 119 deaths and $1.5 million in property damage. The riots highlighted social, economic, and racial tensions in the war-torn nation.
The New York City Draft Riots erupted in July 1863, marking one of the deadliest civil disturbances in American history. As the Civil War raged on, President Lincoln's implementation of mandatory military conscription sparked intense opposition among the city's working-class residents, particularly Irish immigrants who couldn't afford the $300 exemption fee.
What began as a protest against the draft quickly spiraled into four days of violent chaos from July 13-16, 1863. The rioters targeted government buildings, wealthy properties and tragically, the city's African American population. During this dark chapter in New York's history, countless buildings were burned, dozens of people lost their lives and the city's social fabric was torn apart before federal troops finally restored order.
The Outbreak of Violence in July 1863
#The Draft Riots erupted in New York City on July 13, 1863, marking the start of the deadliest civil insurrection in American history. The violence spread rapidly through Manhattan's streets as protestors targeted draft offices military installations.
Key Dates of the Draft Riots
#- July 13: Rioters attacked the Ninth District draft office at Third Avenue and 47th Street at 10:00 AM
- July 14: Violent mobs expanded their attacks to government buildings African American neighborhoods
- July 15: Destruction spread to multiple areas including the Colored Orphan Asylum on Fifth Avenue
- July 16: Federal troops arrived from Gettysburg restored order by evening
| Date | Key Events | Estimated Casualties |
|---|---|---|
| July 13 | Draft office attacks | 12 killed |
| July 14 | Widespread rioting | 30 killed |
| July 15 | Peak violence | 67 killed |
| July 16 | Military intervention | 10 killed |
Initial Spark That Ignited the Unrest
#The riots began when angry protestors converged on the Ninth District draft office during the second round of lottery drawings. Key triggers included:
-
Announcement of 1,236 names for conscription on July 13
-
Publication of draft lists in newspapers morning of the riot
-
Burning of the draft office enrollment records registration books
-
Destruction of telegraph lines to prevent communications with authorities
-
Attacks on police officers attempting to disperse the initial crowd
-
Draft office buildings documentation
-
Military recruiting stations
-
Telegraph communications systems
-
Police precincts responding to unrest
Political and Social Climate of Civil War Era New York
#New York City's social fabric experienced intense strain during the Civil War era due to political divisions, economic disparities, and racial tensions. The city's diverse population of 814,000 in 1860 created a complex landscape of competing interests and social conflicts.
Impact of the Conscription Act
#The Conscription Act of 1863 sparked immediate resistance in New York City's working-class neighborhoods. The law's $300 commutation fee created a two-tiered system that favored wealthy citizens over poor laborers earning an average of $500 annually. Democratic politicians capitalized on this inequity, framing the draft as a "rich man's war but a poor man's fight." The Act heightened existing tensions between:
- Republican supporters of Lincoln's administration
- Democratic opposition led by Governor Horatio Seymour
- Working-class immigrants facing mandatory service
- Wealthy citizens who purchased exemptions
Economic Tensions in the City
#New York's wartime economy exposed deep class divisions and financial inequalities. Key economic factors included:
| Economic Indicator | Statistics (1863) |
|---|---|
| Average worker wage | $500/year |
| Draft exemption fee | $300 |
| Skilled labor wage | $2-3/day |
| Unskilled labor wage | $0.75-1/day |
The city's commercial elite profited from war contracts while working-class residents faced:
- Rising food prices with bread costs increasing 58%
- Housing shortages in immigrant neighborhoods
- Competition for jobs with free Black workers
- Reduced wages in manufacturing sectors
These economic pressures intensified racial animosity as Irish laborers viewed African Americans as economic competitors. The intersection of these financial hardships with racial prejudice created volatile conditions throughout the city's working-class districts.
Five Days of Chaos and Destruction
#The New York City Draft Riots unleashed unprecedented violence across Manhattan from July 13-17, 1863. Rioters destroyed property valued at $1.5 million (equivalent to $31 million today) and claimed the lives of at least 119 people.
Major Sites of Violence
#-
The Ninth District Provost Marshall's Office at Third Avenue and 47th Street burned to the ground on July 13
-
Brooks Brothers clothing store at Catherine and Cherry Streets faced looting by 500 rioters
-
The New York Tribune building on Nassau Street endured multiple arson attempts
-
Police Superintendent John Kennedy suffered severe beating at 46th Street and Third Avenue
-
Five police stations sustained major damage including the 35th Precinct station house
-
The Second Avenue Armory ammunition depot experienced complete destruction by fire
-
Bull's Head Hotel on 44th Street burned after refusing to serve alcohol to rioters
-
The Colored Orphan Asylum at Fifth Avenue and 43rd Street burned on July 13, displacing 233 children
-
Sullivan Street in Greenwich Village saw attacks on 20 Black-owned businesses
-
Rioters destroyed African American homes on Roosevelt Street in Lower Manhattan
-
Black laborers at the docks faced systematic attacks, with 12 documented murders
-
Churches serving Black congregations experienced vandalism including the African Methodist Episcopal Zion Church
-
Multiple Black-owned boarding houses on Carmine Street suffered complete destruction
-
The residence of prominent abolitionists faced targeted attacks, including Rev. Henry Highland Garnet's home
| Location Type | Number Destroyed | Estimated Damages |
|---|---|---|
| Draft Offices | 4 | $175,000 |
| Police Stations | 5 | $230,000 |
| Black Residences | 75+ | $600,000 |
| Public Buildings | 8 | $495,000 |
Military Response and Intervention
#The federal government's military response to the New York City Draft Riots began on July 16, 1863, as veteran troops from the Army of the Potomac arrived from Gettysburg to suppress the violence.
Union Troops Return to New York
#Federal forces totaling 4,000 troops from regiments including the 7th New York Regiment, 65th New York Infantry, and elements of the Invalid Corps arrived in Manhattan. These battle-hardened soldiers, fresh from their victory at Gettysburg, deployed artillery pieces at strategic intersections across the city. Major General John E. Wool coordinated military operations from his headquarters at the St. Nicholas Hotel, establishing a command structure that divided the city into four military districts.
| Military Forces | Number of Troops |
|---|---|
| Army of the Potomac Veterans | 4,000 |
| New York State Militia | 800 |
| Marines and Naval Infantry | 700 |
| Invalid Corps | 500 |
Restoring Order to the City
#The military implemented a three-phase strategy to regain control:
- Secured strategic infrastructure including telegraph offices, customs houses, banks
- Established defensive perimeters around vulnerable neighborhoods like Five Points
- Conducted systematic sweeps through riot-affected areas from north to south
The troops employed decisive force against armed rioters, using fixed bayonets, artillery, and cavalry charges to disperse crowds. Military patrols protected fire companies responding to arson attempts, while gunboats positioned in the East River provided additional firepower support. By July 18, the combined military presence of 6,000 troops restored stability, enabling civilian authorities to resume control of the city.
| Riot Aftermath Statistics | Number |
|---|---|
| Arrests Made | 450 |
| Weapons Seized | 800+ |
| Military Casualties | 30 |
| Days to Restore Order | 3 |
Aftermath and Long-Term Impact
#The New York City Draft Riots left an indelible mark on the city's social fabric with devastating consequences that reshaped civil-military relations. The aftermath brought significant changes to both the physical landscape of New York City and the implementation of the federal draft system.
Casualties and Property Damage
#The final death toll reached 119 confirmed casualties, including 11 Black Americans who were lynched by mob violence. Property damage totaled $1.5 million (equivalent to $31 million in modern currency), with destruction concentrated in Lower Manhattan's commercial districts and predominantly Black neighborhoods. The riots destroyed:
-
50 buildings, including the Colored Orphan Asylum
-
5 police stations with complete structural damage
-
75 Black-owned residences and businesses
-
2 Protestant churches serving Black congregations
-
3 provost marshal offices with draft records
-
Reduced the commutation fee from $300 to $150
-
Implemented payment plans for working-class conscripts
-
Created municipal assistance programs to support families of draftees
-
Established rotating draft locations to prevent concentrated resistance
-
Increased military presence at draft offices during selection dates
-
Instituted a ward-based quota system to ensure fair distribution
-
Added exemptions for sole family providers
| Draft System Changes | Pre-Riots | Post-Riots |
|---|---|---|
| Commutation Fee | $300 | $150 |
| Payment Options | Single payment | Installment plans |
| Draft Locations | Fixed | Rotating |
| Family Support | None | Municipal programs |
| Security Presence | Minimal | Enhanced military |
Key Takeaways
#- The New York City Draft Riots occurred from July 13-16, 1863, marking one of the deadliest civil disturbances in American history
- The riots were triggered by President Lincoln's mandatory military conscription and the $300 exemption fee, which particularly affected working-class and Irish immigrant communities
- At least 119 people lost their lives during the four days of violence, with property damage estimated at $1.5 million (equivalent to $31 million today)
- The riots targeted government buildings, wealthy properties, and the African American community, including the destruction of the Colored Orphan Asylum
- Federal troops from the Army of the Potomac finally restored order on July 16, arriving with 4,000 soldiers fresh from the Battle of Gettysburg
- The aftermath led to significant changes in the draft system, including reducing the commutation fee to $150 and implementing payment plans for working-class conscripts
Conclusion
#The New York City Draft Riots of July 1863 stand as a stark reminder of how social inequality economic hardship and racial tensions can ignite civil unrest. The five days of violence resulted in 119 deaths property damage worth $1.5 million and profound changes to the federal draft system.
The government's response ultimately led to significant reforms including reduced commutation fees payment plans for conscripts and a fairer ward-based quota system. These changes helped prevent future riots while addressing the underlying grievances of working-class New Yorkers.
The Draft Riots remain one of the most significant civil disturbances in American history serving as a powerful lesson about the importance of social equity and responsible governance during times of national crisis.